For the City of Lake Mills, government transparency is built into every day

Twenty miles west of Madison and 50 miles east of Milwaukee, lies a very contented small town called Lake Mills, population 6,200.  Tucked up against Rock Lake, residents here enjoy a close knit community, good schools, wonderful recreational opportunities, and a low crime rate.  Keeping their community growing in a way that retains all the good things they have come to treasure is very important to residents.  So it's no surprise that residents here expect to be kept well-informed about the activities of their local government.  The City of Lake Mills Community and Government TV channels have been meeting this need for nearly forty years. 

Lake Mills has a long history of using its two cable TV PEG (public, education, and government) channels that dates back to the 1980’s when many small to medium-sized communities in Wisconsin went through a high-profile public process to choose between several cable companies vying to serve them.  Offering PEG channels was an important way companies would show they were going to serve the needs of the community, a key selection criterion.  Especially for cities like Lake Mills that were served by local broadcast stations based in big cities like Milwaukee and Madison, having a locally controlled cable channel that would focus on them as a priority was extremely attractive.  Dave Grooman, the city’s Cable TV Operator and IT Specialist, says “The City always supported using the PEG channels to interact with the community and over the years our PEG channels have developed a devoted audience.  That said, we are continually working to promote our channels, especially to newcomers.”  

Promoting the channels is essential especially since Charter/Spectrum moved the PEG channels to the “nosebleed” section of the line up in 2008.  Viewers now find the Lake Mills channels on 993 (government) and 994 (community/education). The program schedule is on the city’s website because Charter/Spectrum does not permit the city to use its Electronic Program Guide.  “Promoting the existence of PEG channels is still the greatest challenge I think PEG managers face,” said Dave.  “I think social media has really helped us get the word out.”

Dave has been working in the field for nearly 40 years.  After receiving a BA in Broadcast Journalism, Dave began his career in 1987 working for Metrovision in Lincoln, Nebraska, where he was the public access coordinator overseeing four PEG channels.  In 1996, he accepted a position with MATA Community Media in Milwaukee, where he worked alongside Executive Director Vel Wiley, managing day-to-day operations and working with community producers.  While at MATA, Dave completed a social media marketing certificate and worked on an associate degree in Network Enterprise Administration from Waukesha County Technical College, which he completed in 2016.  He also worked part-time for the City of Jefferson, managing its cable TV operations. In 2015, Dave left MATA and began working for the City of Lake Mills.

“The City of Lake Mills takes its responsibility to be transparent very seriously,” said Dave, “and our PEG channels are a central way the city accomplishes this.”  Since the 1980’s, coverage by commercial media has only gotten worse.  Broadcast TV and radio still rarely cover Lake Mills and the town’s newspaper, the Lake Mills Leader, publishes only a handful of new articles weekly.  The City, however, provides residents with a clear public record of its activities with gavel-to-gavel video documentation of its meetings, features on its projects, and community events coverage.  “Because of the coverage we do, everything the city does is readily available to residents,” said Dave.  “This is really important because rumors can start and we’re able to put them to rest pretty quickly.” 

The city also makes every effort to reach all of its constituents with the content it produces.  “The way we do that is to distribute programming in different ways to reach different audiences.  We use cable TV, but we also use Facebook and YouTube.  I just noticed an article today about a recent Nielsen survey that reported that Americans spend only 26% of their ‘screen time’ watching streaming services and 64% of their time watching traditional television -- either broadcast or cable TV.  That means it’s still very important that we continue to have a presence on cable television while continuing to reach the audiences using social media for information.” 

Local government meetings are carried live from the council chambers on channel 993, Zoom, Facebook, the city’s website and its YouTube channel.  Those meetings include coverage of City Council, Plan Commission, the Public Works Board, and the School Board. The coverage of City Council is enhanced with the use of a Granicus system that allows people to go directly to a particular agenda item in the video coverage on the city website.  The city also obtains recordings of the Lake Mills Town Board and the Jefferson County Board and makes them available to viewers within 24 hours.  Listening sessions held to discuss major city issues like the comprehensive plan and the selection of the new city manager are also recorded and replayed within 24 hours.  “People can’t say the city didn’t let people know about something,” said Dave. 

When the Covid pandemic started, Lake Mills switched to live hybrid meetings after a $50,000 upgrade in equipment from the federal Cares Act. Hybrid meetings continue to this day. The investment in a Tricaster and upgraded audio has proven to be a good one.  “The system is not only routinely used by our boards and council, but it’s also being used several times a week by our city departments to meet with people off-site,” said Dave.  

Covid also shut down community events and with nothing to cover, Dave directed his time toward developing programs for city departments and tending to his IT duties.  The shift away from covering community events continues.  “There’s a lot going on in city government,” said Dave.  The city has embarked on many development projects and Dave is providing ongoing visual documentation on their progress to the governmental bodies that are responsible, as well as to the public, which in most cases will be voting on them through referendums.  Two weeks ago, Dave put together a presentation for the Public Works Board covering projects at twelve sites.   

Coverage of what is going on in the community that is unrelated to government activities, though, is also important.  Dave said, “I would like to see more participation from the community in providing programming for our community channel.  Although the city does not offer training or have equipment or a studio for people to use, there are five local churches who submit programming and sometimes people submit other programs.”  Besides programs submitted by residents of the Town and City of Lake Mills, the mission of the community channel allows for the carriage of “outside” programming that is educational and entertaining for residents.  Dave often carries programs produced or distributed through media centers in other Wisconsin cities who use the Wisconsin Community Media program sharing library. 

“I’ve been working in the field of community media for nearly forty years, and what I enjoy most is the way PEG media can convey a sense of community.  A good day for me is when I can do a Facebook post about a city employee finding a kid’s bike and locking it up for safekeeping and then there’s a response thanking the employee for its safe return.  Or when someone recognizes me and thanks me for providing coverage of an event.  Or when a county board member tells me that his mother watches every single meeting.  I believe we provide an invaluable service when we offer gavel to gavel coverage of a meeting or complete coverage of an event. When there’s no manipulation or editing.  People trust that.  And having that kind of trust these days is rare and valuable.”

BeloitTV offers students real world production experience embedded in community service

Beloit TV Station Manager Jonathan Kelley

With a full-scale 4K upgrade of Beloit TV now in the rearview mirror, Jonathon Kelley, Station Manager and Adjunct Instructor of Media Studies at Beloit College in Beloit, is finding success with a newly revamped academic program that enables students to combine real world production experience with theory and creative opportunities.  

BeloitTV anchors the Center for Entrepreneurship (CELEB Center), where students come to explore their independent projects and business ideas in music, art, digital media, and other fields.  CELEB is located in an 18,000 square foot space downtown just blocks from campus where someone, sometimes a work-study student, is always in the BeloitTV studio during business hours Monday through Friday.   

Both the CELEB space and BeloitTV have modernized over the last few years.  Jonathon took over management of the station just prior to the upgrade.  “We are completely 4K now,” said Jonathon, “everything you need to make slick and modern productions.”  The studio sports three high-end studio cameras, three teleprompters, an array of backdrops, audio equipment, LED lighting and a control room that has a 4K-capable video processor, a professional grade multi-camera switcher and six monitors for lucky student directors to track the action with. 

Jonathon explains that having high-quality equipment is not only important for creating a quality end-product and to mimic what a student might find in a workplace, but also critical for teaching novices video production.  “Equipment has to function like it is supposed to function when you teach beginners.  If it isn’t working the way it should, if you have to go wiggling cords, and troubleshooting, you can’t learn.  Now with the upgrade, it’s easy to explain to students that if you push this button, ‘this’ will happen.  I can take a complete novice and in 10 – 15 minutes they can be a contributing member of a production team.” 

Jonathon is a graduate of UW-Whitewater and has a BA in Electronic Media and an MS in Mass Communications.  He became interested in video at an early age.  “Even as a kid, when I had to lug a heavy over-the-shoulder camcorder to make a film of a birthday party or the worst movie ever, I had so much fun,” he said.  During high school, Jonathon was the morning DJ on WIBU, a polka radio station that no longer exists.  He got interested in PEG access TV as a way to continue doing his talk show after the radio station changed formats.  During the 1990’s, he was a community producer at WYOU in Madison and he also helped get the Lodi School District PEG access channel up and running.  

Now at Beloit College, he has an opportunity to pass his enthusiasm on to his students.   “I love my job,” said Jonathon.  It’s kinda great to come to work every morning and make a TV show.  Especially with students.  There are lots of bright-eyed and bushy-tailed kids with creative ideas coming in every day.  They think about the little things that can make a production extraordinary.   I train them, manage the facility, and off they go.” 

Most importantly, in his short time with Beloit TV, Jonathon is already seeing students launch careers. “Students are getting jobs in the field as a result of the work they are doing here.  They’re launching careers that they will have for the rest of their lives.  That’s very satisfying,” he said.

Jonathon teaches an introductory and an advanced class in television production every year and offers a third class that varies.  In the intro class, students learn how to operate television production equipment and are required to put in “practicum hours” filming community events. 

Community service is part of the core mission of BeloitTV, which was founded as a PEG (Public, Education, and Government) cable access channel in 1987.  “The primary mission of BeloitTV is to produce and distribute programming of community interest while advancing the education and providing real-world experience for Beloit College students,” said Jonathon.  The door is also open to the public.  BeloitTV appears on Charter Spectrum cable channel 992 and is livestreamed from a Beloit College website.  Programs are also uploaded to Facebook, YouTube and Twitter.  BeloitTV turns a contractual obligation with the city to cover Beloit City Council meetings into an opportunity for students to get real-world experience.  Under normal conditions, Beloit residents are also able to use the facility after being trained.   A few public access shows are now running on the channel, but since the pandemic hit, the studio and field production equipment checkout have been closed to the public.  This summer the media center’s review board will be discussing how to open back up again safely.

Jonathon is able to do a lot of local events coverage with a class of 25 people. “Our students cover on-campus lectures at the library, college sports, and community events,” said Jonathon.  “If it’s open to the public, there’s a good chance that a Beloit student will be there covering it.”  There is a learning curve for first-year students and in the early weeks, the focus is on training.  “In the first half of the semester, students learn the basics of TV production.  Then, half-way through the semester, I give them a written test and what I call a ‘road test.’  I ask them to demonstrate basic production tasks like tilting and pedestaling up, floor manager signals, how to check focus -- so that all first-year students are on the same page by that point.  Then we can create content – not only for the community, but for student producers from the advanced class.  These second-year students produce their own original productions and recruit their crews from first-year students as well as hold auditions for hosts and actors, if needed.”

This year, the third class Jonathon is teaching melds television production skills with film theory.  “We’ve been developing a TNT-type movie series.   Each student in the class picks a public domain film and is required to do an academic criticism of it and produce a brief two to three-minute introduction that includes a synopsis and a review.  Once we decide on a film, we look hard to find the best recording of the film that we can,” said Jonathon.  The end product is a movie series suitable for air on BeloitTV with an in-studio student introduction, the film, and a closing.  “We have 24 different films right now including some horror films like Night of the Living Dead and Christmas-themed programs that we can air around the holidays. Many of the films featured are silent movies like Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplain.  Some of these older films are still wonderful to watch, but handle race in a woefully outdated and stereotypical way.  Students are required to address these in their opening remarks.”

BeloitTV receives funding from the city, the college, and CELEB budgets.  A Beloit city ordinance and a 1987 agreement between the city and Beloit College to share joint responsibility for the fledgling cable access channel has proved to be a win-win for both.  Beloit College offers students real world experience in television production and city residents get local coverage of their community and an opportunity to make their own television productions.  Feedback from the community is very positive.  “We hear from a lot of people who like the programming we are creating,” said Jonathon. 

However, in recent years, difficulties have arisen with Charter Spectrum.   “We’ve been waiting for a digital upgrade.  There has been delay after delay.  Everything is analog now.  We’re using an old 1980’s RF modulator.  It’s been back and forth for over a year.  Now they have given us a firm date of April 21 to complete the upgrade and they are charging us $12,000 to put in a new Drake unit and upgrade the link to the company’s headend.  Basically they’ve told us that if we want an upgrade of the upstream link, we have to pay for it.  Our options are, don’t have things working and worry the transmission equipment dies at any second or we give in and pay what they want.  I don’t have the time or the money to argue with them about it.”   And even after the upgrade, Charter Spectrum will not be carrying Beloit’s programming in HD, which has been the minimum viewing standard since just after the turn of the century.

“The days of cable TV will come to an end – maybe in 20 years,” said Jonathon.  “But until then, we hope to serve that audience.  We could post everything on YouTube, but you have to search it out.  It’s not like the passive experience of TV that so many people are used to.  Cable is a completely different way of viewing content.  Where do you go if you don’t have cable to see local shows?  Roku is not so easy to explain to people.” 

Jonathon talked about how viewership is migrating to the streaming television market, which is undergoing rapid segmentation. Netflix revenue is down as viewers subscribe to one or more studio alternatives like Disney Plus, Paramount Plus, HBO Go, and Peacock.  He noted that eventually there will be consolidation, but in the meantime, if you subscribe to several of them, it’s like paying for a cable subscription, but online.  Jonathon said, “That has serious implications for local PEG access TV and local coverage.”  Municipalities are seeing franchise fees decline as people drop cable and move to one or more streaming services. Per federal law, municipalities may charge companies like Charter Spectrum a franchise fee for using city streets based on a percentage of cable TV revenues, but they cannot assess a fee on revenue generated from the Internet side of a cable company’s business.  “I’ve talked about the situation with management at the college.  What will happen?  We just don’t know.”

“For most of us in the government access TV field, the goal is not to ‘wow’ but to inform,” said Jonathon.  “We are here as a resource -- where the community can come together,” he said.  “It’s not commercially feasible to run a local newspaper or a broadcast channel today. That trend, coupled with the market’s predilection to moving to multiple media sources online, means the need for local content is higher today than ever.  Our role as local media centers is to provide information to audiences wherever they are, including providing information to people not comfortable with getting their information from the Internet.  Keeping the community informed by using cable TV is invaluable and Beloit TV stands behind WCM’s efforts to keep communities on cable TV.”

— Mary Cardona